Skip to main content
Skip to main nav
Skip to secondary nav
Skip to footer nav
Search keyword or item #
search
Toggle Menu
search
Sign In
Sign In or Register
Your Account
0
Search keyword or item #
search
Header Secondary Navigation Desktop
Header Secondary Navigation Desktop Ad - Non-Promo (standard)
Header Secondary Navigation
Shop By Price
Under $30
$30 - $50
$50 - $75
$75 - $100
Over $100
Top Rated
Most Popular
Maple Syrup
Pure Vermont Maple Syrup
Pure Maple Products
Maple Sausage
Maple Chili
Maple Dessert
Shop All Maple
Gift Samplers
Dakin Farm Samplers
Most Popular
Farmhouse Collection
Family Gifts
Office & Snack Gifts
Party Samplers
Baskets & Special Packaging
Shop All Gift Samplers
Bacon & Sausage
Bacon
Breakfast Sausage
Grill Sausage
Snack Sausage
Sausage Entrees
Breakfast Meat Combos
Shop All Bacon & Sausage
Breakfast
Most Popular Breakfasts
Maple Syrup Combos
Breakfast Meat Varieties
Vermont Coffee Company®
Shop All Breakfasts
Ham
Boneless Spiral-Sliced Ham
Bone-In Dinner Ham
Bone-In Spiral-Sliced Ham
Boneless Dinner Ham
Shop All Ham
Ribs & BBQ
BBQ Ribs
Pulled Pork Barbecue
Ham Steaks, Chops & Brisket
BBQ Grill Sausage
Grill Samplers
Shop All BBQ
Poultry
Cob-Smoked Turkey
Spiral-Sliced Turkey
Cob-Smoked Turkey Bacon
Shop All Poultry
Cabot
Cabot Gift Packs
Cabot Aged Cheddar
Mac and Cheese
Cabot Popcorn
Seriously Sharp
Extra Sharp
Sharp
Vintage Choice
Private Stock
Flavored Cheddar
Cabot Cracker Cuts
Light Cheddar
Cabot Snacks
Cabot Yellow Cheddar
Cabot Specialty Items
Shop All Cabot
Cheese
Dakin Farm Selected and Aged Cheese
Charcuterie Samplers
Smoked Cheese
Grafton Village Cheese
Grafton Cave Aged Cheese
Grafton Aged Cheddar
Grafton Flavored Cheddar
Shop All Grafton
Plymouth Cheese
Vermont Artisan Cheese
Cheese Specialties
Cheese Entrees
Swiss Cheese
Shop All Cheese
Entrees
Meals in Minutes
Gourmet Sides
Soups & Chili
Desserts
Shop All Entrees
Pantry
Blake Hill Preserves
Blake Hill Preserve
Blake Hill Savory
Blake Hill Cheese
All Natural Crackers
Mustards, Chutneys & Sauces
Jams, Jellies & Relish
Vermont Clover Honey
New England Tinned Treats
Pancake Mixes
Our Own Fresh Made Fudge
Home
>
Cabot
>
Extra Sharp
SHOP BY CATEGORY
Cabot Gift Packs
Cabot Aged Cheddar
Mac and Cheese
Cabot Popcorn
Seriously Sharp
Extra Sharp
Sharp
Vintage Choice
Private Stock
Flavored Cheddar
Cabot Cracker Cuts
Light Cheddar
Cabot Snacks
Cabot Yellow Cheddar
Cabot Specialty Items
Shop All Cabot
Filter by Ratings
5 Stars
(2)
4+ Stars
(3)
Filter by Price Range
Under $30
(3)
$30 - $50
(1)
Extra Sharp
builtin-u 3ms (318/s)
Sort By
Best Selling
Price Low to High
Price High to Low
Name A - Z
Name Z - A
Customer Reviews
Cabot New York Extra Sharp
From the Farmer's of New York
$5.99
(5 Ratings)
Ship To
MySelf
Someone Else
Cabot Extra Sharp
Aged Perfection!
$6.99
-
$32.99
(56 Ratings)
View Details
Cabot Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar
$5.99
(11 Ratings)
Ship To
MySelf
Someone Else